Yesterday's developments highlight a significant disconnect in AI marketing implementation: whilst content generation dominates AI usage, higher-ROI opportunities in analytics and optimization remain largely untapped. Meanwhile, marketers struggle with data overload—using 230% more data than in 2020 yet lacking proper tools for analysis. Google continues enhancing its AI capabilities in Performance Max campaigns, offering marketers greater control and transparency.
Story #1: New Google Performance Max Controls Improve AI Campaign Management
Publication: Search Engine Journal
Date: 4th May 2025
Source: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-performance-max-updates-may-2025/543254/
What Happened: Google has introduced additional controls for Performance Max campaigns that allow marketers to guide AI more precisely whilst maintaining automation benefits. The update includes expanded negative keyword options, search term reporting improvements, and new asset management tools that provide greater visibility into which creatives are driving performance across channels.
Why It Matters: As AI-driven campaigns become standard practice, marketers need the balance between automation and control. These updates address a common criticism of Performance Max—its "black box" nature—by offering more transparency into how the AI makes decisions whilst preserving the performance advantages of Google's machine learning.
Suggested Actions:
Review your existing Performance Max campaigns to implement the new control features
Use the enhanced search term reporting to identify new negative keywords and optimisation opportunities
Story #2: Marketers Using 230% More Data But Struggling with Analysis
Publication: Supermetrics
Date: 4th May 2025
Source: https://supermetrics.com/blog/marketing-data-utilization-report-2025/
What Happened: According to Supermetrics' latest Marketing Data Report, marketers are now using 230% more data than in 2020, but 56% admit they don't have enough time to analyse it properly, and 38% lack the tools to integrate and report on their data effectively. Interestingly, only 14% cite lack of expertise as a barrier, suggesting the real challenge is in turning vast amounts of data into actionable insights.
Why It Matters: This data paradox has created a situation where marketing teams have access to more information but struggle to derive meaningful insights. Without proper integration tools and analysis processes, marketers risk making decisions based on incomplete understanding despite having massive data repositories at their disposal.
Suggested Actions:
Audit your current martech stack to identify data integration gaps
Prioritise tools that connect data sources rather than adding new tracking solutions
Consider implementing AI-powered analytics to help process and interpret large datasets
Story #3: Content Generation Dominates AI Applications Despite Higher ROI Elsewhere
Publication: MarTech
Date: 4th May 2025
Source: https://martech.org/content-generation-dominates-ai-applications-despite-higher-roi-elsewhere/
What Happened: New research reveals that despite AI's powerful capabilities in predictive analytics, customer journey optimisation, and campaign management, content generation remains the most popular AI application among marketers by a significant margin. This trend persists even as data shows that strategic AI applications often deliver higher ROI than content creation tools.
Why It Matters: Marketers may be missing opportunities to leverage AI beyond addressing immediate pain points like content creation. Whilst generating marketing copy efficiently offers visible time savings, strategic applications of AI in campaign optimisation and customer analysis could deliver greater long-term value and competitive advantage.
Suggested Actions:
Evaluate your current AI toolkit to identify opportunities beyond content generation
Run pilot projects applying AI to data analysis or campaign optimisation
Calculate the potential ROI of strategic AI applications versus content creation tools
Story #4: Personalisation Becoming More Sophisticated with AI-Driven Customer Insights
Publication: McKinsey Digital
Date: 4th May 2025
Source: https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/mckinsey-digital/our-insights/personalization-evolution-2025/
What Happened: McKinsey's latest digital marketing report reveals that AI-driven personalisation has evolved beyond basic demographic segmentation to predictive anticipation of customer needs. Leading organisations are now using AI to analyse customer behaviour patterns across channels and predict future needs before customers explicitly express them. This shift is particularly notable in retail, financial services, and travel sectors.
Why It Matters: As customer expectations for relevant experiences continue to rise, traditional personalisation approaches are becoming less effective. Brands implementing predictive personalisation are seeing significant improvements in conversion rates, with McKinsey reporting an average of 15% increase in revenue and 20% greater customer satisfaction among early adopters.
Suggested Actions:
Assess your current personalisation strategy against predictive capabilities
Identify high-value customer data sources that could enable predictive personalisation
Consider piloting AI-driven personalisation in one customer journey segment
Story #5: Google's AI Overview Feature Expanding Significantly Across Industries
Publication: Search Engine Land
Date: 4th May 2025
Source: https://searchengineland.com/googles-ai-overview-expanding-may-2025-454321/
What Happened: Google's AI Overviews feature is continuing its rapid expansion, with yesterday's update significantly increasing coverage across entertainment, restaurant, and travel queries. According to data from BrightEdge, since March 2025, AI Overviews have grown by 528% for entertainment queries, 387% for restaurant searches, and 381% for travel-related questions.
Why It Matters: This expansion of AI-generated search result summaries is fundamentally changing how users interact with search engines and consume information online. For marketers, this means fewer click-throughs to websites as users get answers directly in search results, requiring new strategies to maintain visibility and engagement in a zero-click search environment.
Suggested Actions:
Audit your SEO strategy for content most vulnerable to AI Overviews
Develop exclusive, in-depth content that adds value beyond what AI summaries can provide
Consider structured data implementation to help inform the AI about your content
Comprehensive Summary
The developments from yesterday paint a fascinating picture of AI's evolving role in marketing, highlighting both significant opportunities and challenges for professionals in the field.
Perhaps most telling is the disconnect between how marketers are currently using AI and where the highest value potential lies. MarTech's research reveals that despite the impressive capabilities of AI in predictive analytics, campaign optimisation, and customer journey mapping, most marketers continue to focus primarily on content generation. This fixation on addressing immediate pain points through content creation, whilst understandable, may be causing many to miss the strategic applications that could deliver significantly higher ROI.
This pattern aligns with Supermetrics' findings on the data paradox facing marketing teams. Despite having access to 230% more data than just five years ago, the majority of marketers lack either the time (56%) or the tools (38%) to extract meaningful insights. This creates a situation where teams are drowning in data whilst starving for actionable intelligence—precisely the type of challenge that strategic AI applications could help solve.
Google's continued evolution of its Performance Max campaigns reflects recognition of this tension. The latest updates provide marketers with more control and transparency whilst preserving the performance benefits of AI-driven optimisation. By offering expanded negative keyword options and improved search term reporting, Google is addressing the common criticism that AI-powered campaigns operate as "black boxes," giving marketers more visibility into how decisions are made whilst maintaining the efficiency advantages of machine learning.
Meanwhile, the rapid expansion of Google's AI Overviews feature across entertainment, restaurant, and travel queries signals a fundamental shift in how users interact with search engines. The dramatic growth rates—528% for entertainment, 387% for restaurants, and 381% for travel since March—suggest that zero-click searches will become increasingly common, challenging marketers to develop new strategies for visibility and engagement.
McKinsey's research on personalisation evolution offers a glimpse of where marketing's future with AI lies. The shift from demographic segmentation to predictive anticipation represents a quantum leap in capability, with early adopters seeing significant improvements in conversion rates, revenue, and customer satisfaction. This approach leverages AI's ability to process vast amounts of data and identify patterns that human analysts might miss, creating experiences that feel remarkably intuitive to customers.
As we move further into 2025, the distinction between tactical and strategic AI applications will likely widen. Organisations that can effectively balance immediate efficiency gains from tools like content generation with more transformative applications in data analysis, customer journey optimisation, and predictive personalisation will gain significant advantages in both effectiveness and competitive positioning.
Key Takeaways
Look beyond content generation: While AI content tools offer immediate efficiency gains, the highest ROI opportunities often lie in strategic applications like predictive analytics, customer journey optimisation, and campaign management.
Address the data integration challenge: Before collecting more data, focus on connecting existing sources and implementing tools that can turn information into actionable insights.
Prepare for zero-click search dominance: With Google's AI Overviews expanding rapidly across industries, develop strategies that deliver value beyond what can be summarised in search results.
Evolve personalisation strategies: Move beyond basic demographic segmentation toward predictive anticipation of customer needs using AI-powered behavioural analysis.
How-To Spotlight: Implementing Negative Keywords in Performance Max
Google's latest Performance Max update offers expanded control through negative keywords. Here's how to implement them effectively:
Audit search term reports to identify irrelevant or low-converting queries
Group negative keywords into themed lists (e.g., competitor terms, irrelevant industries)
Apply negative keywords at campaign level through the new controls interface
Monitor performance impact to ensure excluding terms improves overall results
Regularly review and update your negative keyword lists as campaign data accumulates
This approach helps you maintain the efficiency benefits of AI optimisation while preventing wasted spend on irrelevant searches.
Share this post